All articles Pricing and ROI

Fixed-Price vs Time & Materials: Which Costs Less Over 12 Months?

The choice between fixed-price and time & materials (T&M) BIM coordination is not just a procurement preference. It is a financial decision that compounds across every project. Over a 12-month period with multiple projects, the total cost difference between the two models becomes substantial — consistently favouring fixed-price.

Amer Agha Apr 22, 2026 2 min read
Fixed-Price vs Time & Materials: Which Costs Less Over 12 Months?

Short answer: Fixed-price BIM coordination costs less over 12 months. In a worked example of 4 projects each estimated at €30,000, time and materials coordination with overruns plus PM overhead totals €175,000, while fixed-price with a 15% risk premium and lighter PM oversight totals €142,000 — a €33,000 (19%) saving. The fixed-price route also gives complete budget certainty on every project.

The reason is structural: T&M incentivises the coordinator to log hours, while fixed-price incentivises the coordinator to deliver efficiently. This incentive misalignment costs real money on every project.

The 12-Month Comparison

Consider a mid-sized consulting engineer or contractor running 4 coordination projects in a 12-month period, each with an initial coordination scope estimated at €30,000.

T&M Model (Hourly Rate)

On an hourly-rate engagement, the initial estimate of €30,000 (375 hours at €80/hr) is exactly that — an estimate. Design revisions, additional coordination cycles, and scope evolution extend the programme beyond initial assumptions. Industry experience shows T&M coordination overruns by 30–50% on complex projects.

ProjectInitial EstimateActual Cost (35% avg overrun)Overrun
Project 1€30,000€40,500+€10,500
Project 2€30,000€39,000+€9,000
Project 3€30,000€42,000+€12,000
Project 4€30,000€37,500+€7,500
Total€120,000€159,000+€39,000

Add management overhead (20% PM time at €80K salary, allocated across 4 projects):

PM overhead per project€4,000
PM overhead total€16,000
Total cost (T&M + overhead)€175,000

Fixed-Price Model

On a fixed-price MEP BIM coordination engagement, the coordination cost is agreed before work begins and does not change. The coordinator absorbs the risk of additional cycles and design revisions within the fixed fee. The fee is typically 10–15% above the T&M estimate to account for risk transfer (see how this compares with other pricing models in the MEP BIM coordination pricing guide).

ProjectFixed Fee (15% premium)Actual CostOverrun
Project 1€34,500€34,500€0
Project 2€34,500€34,500€0
Project 3€34,500€34,500€0
Project 4€34,500€34,500€0
Total€138,000€138,000€0

PM overhead (5% PM time, self-managing partner):

PM overhead per project€1,000
PM overhead total€4,000
Total cost (fixed + overhead)€142,000

The Bottom Line

ModelAnnual Coordination CostAnnual PM OverheadAnnual Total
T&M (hourly)€159,000€16,000€175,000
Fixed-price€138,000€4,000€142,000
Saving (fixed-price)€33,000 (19%)

The fixed-price model saves €33,000 per year — 19% of the T&M total — while providing complete budget certainty on every project.

FAQ

Don't fixed-price providers just inflate their fees to cover the risk?

Yes, and it is still cheaper. The 10–15% risk premium on a fixed-price fee is less than the 30–50% overrun that T&M engagements actually experience. The premium buys certainty, which is more valuable than an optimistic estimate that consistently misses.

What happens if the scope changes on a fixed-price project?

Scope changes are handled through a variation mechanism. If the client adds floors, changes the building design, or introduces new disciplines, the fixed-price is adjusted through a formal scope change — just as it would be on any construction contract.

Artificial Modelling uses fixed-price coordination exclusively. No hourly billing. No overruns. No surprises. Get your fixed-price quote →

fixed price vs time materials bim bim pricing model comparison fixed fee bim coordination time materials bim cost
Artificial Modelling logo

MSc aBIMM (TU Dublin)

Founder, artificial MODELLING

15+ years MEPF experience

Amer Agha founded Artificial Modelling in 2020 after MEPF site and coordination work dating back to 2009, and was Lead BIM Coordinator at Jones Engineering on the New Children's Hospital in Dublin.

Last updated: Apr 23, 2026

Describe your project

We'll get back to you within 48 hours with a fixed-price proposal.

Let's work together

Your next project
deserves better.

Clash-free · Fixed price · Delivered.

Send us your project brief →

+48 534 455 075  ·  amer@artificialmodelling.com  ·  Wrocław, Poland

© 2026 Artificial Modelling · Wrocław, PolandMEP BIM · Fire Protection · AutomationWritten, designed & built by Amer Agha